ScalingStacks

4.3 Surfaces and cube morphisms

Let UU be a closed disk in the plane ℝ2\mathbb{R}^{2} and U˙\dot{U} the interior of UU so that U=∂U∪U˙.U=\partial U\cup\dot{U}. Let T′T^{\prime} be a tangle in (ℝ2∖U˙)×[0,1](\mathbb{R}^{2}\setminus\dot{U})\times[0,1] with mm points (where mm is even) on the boundary ∂U×[0,1]\partial U\times[0,1] and TT a generic projection of T′T^{\prime} on ℝ2∖U˙.\mathbb{R}^{2}\setminus\dot{U}. The intersection of TT with ∂U\partial U consists of mm points. Denote them by p1,…,pmp_{1},\dots,p_{m} (see an example on the diagram below, ∂U\partial U is shown by a dashed circle).

[Uncaptioned image]

Let ℐ\mathcal{I} be the set of double points of T.T. Pick two systems Q0Q_{0} and Q1Q_{1} of m2\frac{m}{2} simple disjoints arcs in UU with ends in points p1,…​pmp_{1},\dots p_{m}:

[Uncaptioned image]

Then Q0∪TQ_{0}\cup T and Q1∪TQ_{1}\cup T (here and further on we denote them by P0P_{0} and P1P_{1} respectively) can be considered as two plane diagrams of links in ℝ3:\mathbb{R}^{3}:

[Uncaptioned image]

To P0P_{0} and P1P_{1} there are associated ℐ\mathcal{I}-cubes VP0V_{P_{0}} and VP1.V_{P_{1}}.

Let SS be a compact oriented surface in U×[0,1]U\times[0,1] such that the boundary of SS is the union of Q0×{0},Q1×{1}Q_{0}\times\{0\},Q_{1}\times\{1\} and (p1∪⋯∪pm)×[0,1].(p_{1}\cup\dots\cup p_{m})\times[0,1]. To SS we associate an ℐ\mathcal{I}-cube map

ψS:VP0⟶VP1\psi_{S}:V_{P_{0}}\longrightarrow V_{P_{1}}

as follows. For each ℒ⊂ℐ\mathcal{L}\subset\mathcal{I} we must construct a map

ψS,ℒ:VP0​(ℒ)​{−|ℒ|}⟶VP1​(ℒ)​{−|ℒ|}\psi_{S,\mathcal{L}}:V_{P_{0}}(\mathcal{L})\{-|\mathcal{L}|\}\longrightarrow V_{P_{1}}(\mathcal{L})\{-|\mathcal{L}|\} (57)

and check the commutativity of diagrams (29).

To ℒ\mathcal{L} there is associated a resolution T⁡(ℒ)T(\mathcal{L}) of double points of T.T. Thus T⁡(ℒ)T(\mathcal{L}) is a collection of simple closed curves and arcs in ℝ2∖U̇\mathbb{R}^{2}\setminus\mbox{\.{U}} with ends in p1,…,pm.p_{1},\dots,p_{m}. Then (by (40)

VP0​(ℒ)\displaystyle V_{P_{0}}(\mathcal{L}) =\displaystyle= F⁡(T⁡(ℒ)∪Q0)​{−|ℒ|}\displaystyle F(T(\mathcal{L})\cup Q_{0})\{-|\mathcal{L}|\} (58)
VP1​(ℒ)\displaystyle V_{P_{1}}(\mathcal{L}) =\displaystyle= F⁡(T⁡(ℒ)∪Q1)​{−|ℒ|}\displaystyle F(T(\mathcal{L})\cup Q_{1})\{-|\mathcal{L}|\} (59)

where FF is the functor described in Section 2.3 ( T⁡(ℒ)∪Q0T(\mathcal{L})\cup Q_{0} and T⁡(ℒ)∪Q1T(\mathcal{L})\cup Q_{1} are collections of simple closed curves on the plane, so that we can apply functor FF to them).

Let S′S^{\prime} be a surface in ℝ2×[0,1]\mathbb{R}^{2}\times[0,1] which is SS inside U×[0,1]U\times[0,1] and T⁡(ℒ)×[0,1]T(\mathcal{L})\times[0,1] outside U×[0,1].U\times[0,1]. Map F⁡(S′)F(S^{\prime})

F⁡(S′):F⁡(T⁡(ℒ)∪Q0)⟶F⁡(T⁡(ℒ)∪Q1)F(S^{\prime}):F(T(\mathcal{L})\cup Q_{0})\longrightarrow F(T(\mathcal{L})\cup Q_{1}) (60)

is a graded map of RR-modules of degree χ⁡(S′)=χ⁡(S)−m2.\chi(S^{\prime})=\chi(S)-\frac{m}{2}. Define ψS,ℒ\psi_{S,\mathcal{L}} as this map, shifted by |ℒ||\mathcal{L}|:

ψS,ℒ=F(S′){−|ℒ|}:VP0(ℒ){−|ℒ|}⟶VP1(ℒ){−ℒ|}\psi_{S,\mathcal{L}}=F(S^{\prime})\{-|\mathcal{L}|\}:V_{P_{0}}(\mathcal{L})\{-|\mathcal{L}|\}\longrightarrow V_{P_{1}}(\mathcal{L})\{-\mathcal{L}|\} (61)

The commutativity condition (29) is immediate. We sum up our result as

0PL9

Proposition 10 The map

ψS:VP0⟶VP1\psi_{S}:V_{P_{0}}\longrightarrow V_{P_{1}} (62)

is a degree χ⁡(S)−m2\chi(S)-\frac{m}{2} map of ℐ\mathcal{I}-cubes.

Everything in this section extends to the case when the diagrams Q0Q_{0} and Q1Q_{1} are allowed to have simple closed circles in addition to m2\frac{m}{2} simple disjoint acts joining points p1,…​pm.p_{1},\dots p_{m}. For instance, Q0Q_{0} may look like

[Uncaptioned image]

In this more general case to each compact oriented surface SS in U×[0,1]U\times[0,1] such that the boundary of SS is the union of Q0×{0},Q1×{1}Q_{0}\times\{0\},Q_{1}\times\{1\} and (p1∪⋯∪pm)×[0,1],(p_{1}\cup\dots\cup p_{m})\times[0,1], in exactly the same fashion as before, we associate an ℐ\mathcal{I}-cube map

ψS:VP0⟶VP1\psi_{S}:V_{P_{0}}\longrightarrow V_{P_{1}} (63)

This map is a graded map of cubes over R​-mod0R{\mbox{-mod}_{0}} of degree equal to the Euler characteristic of SS minus m2.\frac{m}{2}.

Tensoring the map ψS\psi_{S} with the identity map of the skew-commutative nn-cube EℐE_{\mathcal{I}} and passing to associated complexes, we obtain a map of complexes of graded RR-modules

ψS′:C¯​(P0)⟶C¯​(P1)\psi^{\prime}_{S}:\overline{C}(P_{0})\longrightarrow\overline{C}(P_{1}) (64)

In general this map is not a morphism in the category Kom​(R​-mod0)\mbox{Kom}(R{\mbox{-mod}_{0}}) of complexes of graded RR-modules and grading-preserving homomorphism, as it shifts the grading by χ⁡(S)−m2,\chi(S)-\frac{m}{2}, but ψS′\psi^{\prime}_{S} becomes a morphism in Kom​(R​-mod0)\mbox{Kom}(R{\mbox{-mod}_{0}}) when the grading of C¯​(P0)\overline{C}(P_{0}) or C¯​(P1)\overline{C}(P_{1}) is appropriately shifted.

Original mathematics by the credited authors. Source collection and HTML conversion remain in progress.

Mikhail Khovanov

Original source: arXiv:math/9908171v2